Sorry to what?


Why is the respected Tempo apologizing over a misguided complaint?Catholics apparently took umbrage with Tempo’s latest cover, which depicted Suharto and his children in a scene reminiscent of The last Supper by Da Vinci.

“The painting has a deep meaning for Catholics as it’s about the holy journey of Jesus and his disciples, but Tempo has disrespected it by replacing the holy persons with the corrupt Soeharto’s family,” Catholic Students Alumni Forum head Hermawi Taslim told The Jakarta Post.

Consider the irony of the statement: An Indonesian Catholic protesting over the mistreatment of a painting by an Italian artist. If history is correct at all the painting has not factual resemblence at all to Christ and his disciples. Christ and Co. were Middle Eastern chaps, swarthy of skin, curly of hair and looks nothing like the Caucasions of Da Vinci’s depiction which would be culturally insensitive if painted today.

Besides so what if Tempo satirized the holy persons? Would this make them any less holy? Would God, if she exists, give a toss? Does this incident speak more of Tempo’s insensitivity (and subsequent lack of spine to apologize so readily) or the faith of the protesters?

clipped from thejakartapost.com
   
 

‘Tempo’ apologizes for controversial Da Vinci cover

The Jakarta Post, Jakarta

Leading weekly magazine Tempo has apologized to the Catholic community for its cover depicting a satirical version of The Last Supper by Leonardo Da Vinci.

Tempo chief editor Thoriq Hadad said the magazine would publish the apology in Wednesday’s issue of Koran Tempo newspaper, online newsportal Tempointeraktif and the magazine’s next issue.

“We also decided to change the cover of our magazine’s English-language edition,” he said.

The apology came after representatives of eight Catholic organizations went to the magazine’s office Tuesday to protest over the cover, which they said had offended them.

The cover portrays the late former president Soeharto having dinner with his six children, following the same composition as Da Vinci’s masterpiece.

  blog it

6 responses to “Sorry to what?”

  1. oh come on! you’re kidding me… but the picture was so perfect… i thought our press had gained freedom after suharto’s done in 1998. but then again, i kept forgetting that indonesians do live in a hypersensitive religious community.

    Like

  2. Yeah right. It was only a mild protest. And you’re are the one blowing out of proportions.

    Put Mohammad there and lets see if there are any riots.

    You go first Unspun followed by dinysays.

    Go on …go on…. please…

    Like

  3. Think it was more to do with fairness in the Indonesian context. It may well have just been a screw-up, always a reasonable assumption in Indonesia. But here’s some reasonable interpretations:

    Some people are seeing Soeharto as a saviour or even some kind of prophet. We can’t depict him as Mohammad, so let’s go the Christian prophet — they’ re a weak and meek (wanting to inherit the earth), and wouldn’t complain.

    Or:

    A roundabout dig at CSIS’s earlier support of Soeharto ?

    I’d go for the screw-up interpretation.

    But given how sensitive the Muslims are and the fact that Tempo wouldn’t DARE do something as risque where Islam was concerned, isn’t the Catholic protest fair enough ?

    Like

  4. @Sovind: Tsk. Tsk. Dishonest argument. Just because some Muslims are intolerant does not make it ok for some Catholics to be intolerant. Two wrong don’t make a right and an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.

    Under discussion is the intolerant behavior of Catholics. Let’s keep to that.

    Blowing things put of proportion with a mere blog posting? Now who’s exaggerating?

    Like

  5. Sovind, your reaction is exactly what I meant by ‘hypersensitive community’. I’m seeing the picture as an ironic satire to Suharto and the rest of Cendana clan. No wonder riots kept going back home, people can’t relax their muscles around the mouth and just smirk, if a smile is hesitated.

    Like

  6. […] 25, 2008 by unspun Question: what’s the difference between intolerant Catholic wallahs and intolerant Islamic wallahs?Answer: […]

    Like

Leave a comment