Large has-been international PR firm going for MTB job?


There will always fools rushing in where angels fear to tread.

The Malaysian Tourism Board’s advertisement in the Jakarta Post looking for professional PR help, which was coincidentally placed after Malaysian Tourism Minister Tengku Adnan made his boo boo statement over bloggers and women, is arousing some amusing reactions among the industry players in Jakarta.

One large international PR firm, regarded as a has-been by most people in the industry, is obviously very eager to go for the business, not realizing that the MTB has a cultural rather than a PR problem. The firm, which belongs to one of the world’s largest marketing communications groups, is busy sending out qustionnaires to their friends and journalists for a perception audit, the usual stuff that PR firms do to try to convince the client that they know what people think about the client. Last heard they were not polling bloggers.

Another international PR firm, which has but a small presence in Jakarta, was also interested but they decided against the pitch becuse they did not have the manpower resources.

One freelance consultant for a local established PR firm was also interested in the business and had a novel approach. He phoned Unspun to ask if moi was pitching for the business. When Unspun replied that, contrary to conventional wisdom, Unspun was still in possession of his cognitive faculties, he asked Unspun for advice instead on how much to quote the MTB. “From what they describd in the briefing document,” he said, “it looks like they are asking for US$10,000 to US$15,000 of worth of acivities in fees alone.”

Unspun laughed: “You’ll be extremely lucky if you get US$5,000 per month is my guess.”

“What!? But they want to conduct a national campaign in Indonesia with lots of activities…” he sounded perplexed.

Unspun said it as up to him but from what Unspun knows about Malaysian bureaucrats, they do not understand PR, how much it is worth and how much it can do. Their comprehension of PR does not distinguish between PR consultants and Events Organizers and besides, we all know what the problems are in Malaysia that prevent more Indonesians from going there. It has to do with obtuse politicians and bureaucrats more interested in jilat pantat and flexing their little muscles than really attracting tourists to Malaysia. Solve that and doing PR for Malaysia will be a breeze.

3 responses to “Large has-been international PR firm going for MTB job?”

  1. […] PR firm that is pitching for the Malaysian Tourism Board account sure has its job cut out. Imagine recommending a blogging […]

    Like

  2. achmadsudarsono Avatar
    achmadsudarsono

    Unspun,

    At first I was incredulous reading your accounts of Malaysian bureaucrats and how they could be so stupid in the face of reality.

    Then I remembered my student days in the 1990s. I remembered the televised broadcast of a Malaysian minister personally cutting the hair of a Malaysian heavy-metal (or was it just hard-rock) band ?

    Then I remembered low-level Australian immigration and customs officials interviewing people coming into that country.

    So how’s this — WHY do you think they’re so apparently dumb ? The system rewards blind obedience ? They are actually short in the grey-matter (I don’t think so). They’re only accountable upwards ?

    Please help. Am stumped.

    Like

  3. Achmad: Malaysian Ministers act this way not so much because they are stupid, although a few of them are, but more so because they are creatures of a political system of patronage.

    In this system what gets you to the top are the courtier’s skills of flattery, hagiography and willingness to do one’s bosses’ biddings.

    They become ministers in as a reward for political favors done or votes delivered, not for their IQ or EQ.

    They are like spoilt children; they behave like brats because it is the only way they know. Unless spoilt brats get a spanking now and then they do not learn any better.

    Unfortunately in Malaysia the press is so controlled and the opposition so muzzled that nobody has any effective means to give them a good whack. Then blogs came along…

    Like

Leave a reply to achmadsudarsono Cancel reply